ACCUMULATING PERIPHERALS


Are math majors better at reading than English majors? by mattsteinglass
April 21, 2010, 1:42 am
Filed under: Education | Tags: , , , , , , ,

Well, math majors do have the highest Reading SAT scores of any major, according to this study Kevin Drum pointed to yesterday. And this really isn’t surprising. That’s because, of all the majors in the study, math is the most selective on cognitive ability. In other words, basically anyone who can get into college can major in “soft” subjects like English or…economics. (Heh. It’s true; look at the data. Also, philosophy majors have slightly higher Math SATs than economics majors.) But just to do the coursework in math or physics, you have to have extremely high SAT scores, in both math and reading. In the researchers’ terms, math and physics seem to have a “cognitive threshold”: even if you’re very hard-working, without high SAT scores, you can’t “achieve mastery”, i.e. maintain a GPA above 3.5 and have a shot at getting into grad school:

To reiterate, SATM ≈ 600 seems to be the lowest score at which even a very motivated student has a chance for mastery. From the data one might guess that only for SATM well above 700 do students have more than a 50 percent chance of obtaining GPA > 3.5. That is, a student with average motivation or conscientiousness probably needs SATM well above 700 to have a high probability of obtaining mastery.

We were unable to find any similar threshold (either in SATR or SATM ) in other majors, including economics, sociology, history, philosophy, biology, chemistry, etc.

It’s amusing to note that math majors have higher English SATs than English majors, but it’s kind of a linguistic trick. The point is that math is simply the most cognitively selective major. Math majors also have higher Math SATs than physics majors, which isn’t particularly predictable and doesn’t tell us anything obvious about math or physics as disciplines. This is basically all selection effect. If you’re wondering whether studying more math will get your kid to read better…well, that’s entirely possible, but it requires a different study.


18 Comments so far
Leave a comment

[…] Ar&#1077 math majors better &#1072t reading t&#1211&#1072&#1495 English majors? – Matt Steingl… […]

Pingback by Forex interest rates? | Currency Trading Exchange Guide

I’m here to tell you, econ majors can be dumb as dirt. But they sound smart on blogs, don’t they? I mean “heteroskedasticity?” “GDI?” Jump back!

Comment by citifieddoug

[…] Ar&#1077 math majors better &#1072t reading t&#1211&#1072&#1495 English majors? – Matt Steingl… […]

Pingback by NY Forex Market Buzz – USD firms on Fed outlook & lower oil | Currency Trading Exchange Guide

[…] Are math majors better at reading than English majors? – Matt … […]

Pingback by Business Marketing: Revealed, The Shocking 100 Million Dollars Business Marketing “Secret” | The Secret Law of Attraction Review

[…] Ar&#1077 math majors better &#1072t reading t&#1211&#1072&#1495 English majors? – Matt Steingl… […]

Pingback by U.S. Dollar Firm Against Majors | Currency Trading Exchange Guide

[…] Are math majors better at reading than English majors? – Matt Steinglass – Accumulating … […]

Pingback by Oak Floor - prefinished treads and risers for you stair - Best Wood Flooring

[…] Are math majors better at reading than English majors? – Matt … […]

Pingback by Beat Cancer Naturally – Natural Therapies to Conquer Cancer Today | Health: Diet & Fitness, Mind & Mood, Longevity, Conditions Guide

Now that this site is getting spammed, I wonder if the comments are improved.

Comment by citifieddoug

[…] Are math majors better at reading than English majors? – Matt … […]

Pingback by Baby Strollers Tips And Advice | Lil Baby Care

[…] Are math majors better at reading than English majors? – Matt … […]

Pingback by Modify Cars » Blog Archive » INCREASE YOUR VEHICLE’S PERFORMANCE

Doing word problems in math requires very careful reading to parse essential elements and extract data.
Reading for English majors is not about data extraction.

Comment by jcalton

Allow me to append that comment by proposing that English majors read novels, novels, and short stories thematically, or for emotional or introspective purposes (somewhat synonymous with B.S.).

Math majors read short paragraphs for informational purposes….standardized tests ask you to read short paragraphs for informational purposes.

English majors are probably good at reading novels, but math majors are very good at reading test questions. One skill is far more valuable than the other if you are going to be measured by standardized test scores.

Comment by jcalton

[…] Are math majors better at reading than English majors? – Matt … […]

Pingback by McCain Care Leaves Seniors Behind | Health: Diet & Fitness, Mind & Mood, Longevity, Conditions Guide

[…] Are math majors better at reading than English majors? – Matt … […]

Pingback by How to build an outdoor barbecue grill out of bricks? | Build Low Cost Barbecue

Selection effect, indeed. Most of the math-major types I spar with on line act astonished whenever I refer to a dictionary for a word definition–they seem to regard this as cheating. That gives you some clue as to their degree of friendliness, as a group, with words and word combinations (the stuff of reading, in my experience). They also lack linear tracking ability when it comes to following a sentence from first word to last, especially if there are clauses along the way.

Math and engineering types are the most astonishing inept readers I’ve ever encountered, short of people who simply can’t read. Writing-wise, they tend to use “big” words for effect and blow a temple vein whenever one of their four-syllable adjectives turns out to be mean something else.

I’m sure there are plenty of exceptions to the rule, but they seem to walk softly in cyberspace.

Comment by savio

[…] Are science conference meliorate at datum than English majors? – Matt … […]

Pingback by Why Haven’t I Lost Weight? Learn The Real Reason You Are Fat & How You Can Reverse This Right Now! – Fat Burning Program | Body Weight Loss

[…] Are math majors better at reading than English majors? – Matt … […]

Pingback by How To Pay Back Student Loans | Student Loans Repayment

[…] Are math majors better at reading than English majors? – Matt … […]

Pingback by Why Buy a Samsung Flat Panel TV? | Samsung Flat Screen TV




Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s



%d bloggers like this: